How to get your first book reviews ethically

BookPros banner: How to get your first book reviews ethically

Waiting for your first review feels slow, and it’s tempting to look for a shortcut. We’d steer you away from every shortcut, because the penalty for getting this wrong is far bigger than the benefit. This guide covers what Amazon allows, what it doesn’t, and a plan that stays on the safe side.

Why this matters more than it seems

Amazon’s Community team manages customer reviews, and its KDP help page says reviews that violate the Community Guidelines get removed. A review given in exchange for anything of value is treated as invalid. Amazon’s Community Guidelines also set out the consequences: Amazon says it may remove content and suspend or terminate accounts that violate them. Read that page in full before you do anything with reviews. A problem with your account is a far bigger loss than one missing review.

The honest part: most books get few reviews in the first months, even when everything is done correctly. A slow start doesn’t mean your book is failing. It usually means few people have seen it yet.

The rule of thumb we use is simple. If a reader would feel differently about a review once they knew about the arrangement behind it, don’t make the arrangement. A review should be a reader’s own opinion, written freely, with nothing owed and nothing offered. Everything below follows from that idea, and it’s easier to remember than a list of rules.

What is not allowed

Based on Amazon’s KDP help page on customer reviews and its Community Guidelines, treat all of the following as off limits:

  • Paying for reviews. Amazon’s guidelines prohibit reviews posted in exchange for compensation. That includes services that charge a fee for a review.
  • Gifts of any other kind. The KDP page says offering anything beyond a free or discounted copy, including gift cards, will invalidate a review, and the Community team will remove it.
  • Conditions on the review. You can’t require a review in exchange for a copy, and you can’t try to influence what the review says or how many stars it gives.
  • Review swaps. Amazon’s guidelines don’t use the term “review swap,” but they prohibit coordinating with others and reviews given in exchange for compensation, so we advise against “I’ll review yours if you review mine,” even informally.
  • Reviews from people you know. Amazon’s Community Guidelines don’t allow people to review products from authors they have a personal connection with, including friends, relatives, employers, business associates and competitors. A kind review from your sister can be removed.
  • Asking for positive reviews only. KDP says you may not attempt to influence a review, so “leave us five stars” or “only review if you loved it” is risky. Ask for honest feedback, nothing more specific.
  • Review requests inside your listing. KDP’s metadata rules say the book description can’t include reviews, quotes, testimonials or requests for customer reviews.

What is allowed

  • Free or discounted copies with no strings. The KDP page says you may provide them as long as you don’t require a review in exchange or attempt to influence the review.
  • Asking readers for an honest review. We believe a plain, neutral request is within the rules, as long as you don’t tie it to a reward or steer the rating.
  • Amazon’s own programs. Amazon has its own programs, such as Editorial Reviews, A+ Content and Amazon Vine. Eligibility and how each works depend on your book and account, so check the current rules before you plan around them.
  • Goodreads giveaways. A giveaway puts copies in front of readers. Confirm the current terms on Goodreads. As our own advice, don’t contact winners to demand a review.
  • A reader newsletter. Your own list is the most reliable audience you can build, and you can tell it about your book honestly.
  • Honest editorial features. A site that writes about your book on its own terms is publicity, not a purchased review.

A safe step-by-step plan

1. Build a small ARC list of genuine readers

An ARC is an advance review copy. Choose people who actually read your genre: readers in genre groups and newsletter subscribers, none of them friends, relatives, business associates or authors who compete with you. Keep the list modest, since a handful of real readers beats a long list of strangers.

2. Send the copy with no conditions

Say it plainly: “Here’s a free copy. You don’t have to review it, and there’s no expectation about what you’d think.” Don’t mention stars. Don’t offer anything in return. If they never write a review, that’s fine.

3. Ask once, after they’ve had time to read

One short, neutral message is enough: “If you enjoyed the book and feel like leaving an honest review on Amazon, it helps other readers decide. No pressure either way.” Then stop. Don’t follow up repeatedly, and don’t react to a review, whether it’s good or bad.

4. Start a newsletter early

Even a short list gives you a place to say the book is live. Tell subscribers where to find it and that honest reviews help other readers. Our guide to promoting your book without a publisher budget covers other low-cost ways to find readers.

5. Pursue honest editorial attention

Our free Author Spotlights are editorial features. They aren’t a review service, and they’re never conditional on you or anyone else leaving a review. BookPros never trades features for reviews, and we’d turn down any arrangement that tried to link the two.

6. Keep your own house clean

Don’t review your own book, don’t ask relatives to, and keep a simple record of what you sent and when. If a review you expected goes missing, don’t repost it or argue about it. KDP says the reviewer can contact the Amazon Community team, and it gives authors no separate appeal.

Where reviews fit in the larger picture

Reviews matter, but they’re one part of a launch. If you’re still getting your book ready, the step-by-step self-publishing guide shows where this stage sits, and the free 30-Day Author Checklist keeps launch tasks in order. Budget matters too, so see what it costs to self-publish before you spend on anything review related. If you want a structured, optional next step, The BookPros Author Blueprint is a 104-page guide for $19.

A short checklist before you send anything

  • Is the copy free, with no payment, gift or favor attached?
  • Have you said the reader is free not to review it?
  • Have you avoided mentioning a star rating or “positive” feedback?
  • Is the reader someone without a close personal or business tie to you, and not a competing author?
  • Are you asking only once?

If you can answer yes to all five, you’re on solid ground. If any answer is no, pause and read Amazon’s pages again.

Sources

Checked November 2026. Policies and prices change, so confirm on the platform before you act.

The Author Blueprint
Turn what you just read into your own book.
The Author Blueprint is a step-by-step system for writing, publishing, and selling your own book, built from the exact process used on this site. $19, instant download.

Get the Blueprint →