“Should I query agents or just self-publish?” is a fair question, and neither answer is wrong. It depends on what you want the book to do for you, so here are the real trade-offs, with sources, and one step you can take today.
What traditional publishing gives you
A traditional deal usually means an agent first, then a publisher that buys the rights to your book. It still offers a few things that are hard to get on your own:
- An advance. This is money paid before the book sells a copy. The Authors Guild explains that it is an advance against royalties, and in most cases you don’t have to repay the part that never earns out (you do if you breach the contract, for example by missing your delivery date).
- Bookstore and library reach. Publishers have sales teams that pitch to bookstores and libraries. Self-publishers can get into the same distributors, but nobody sells the book in for you. KDP’s own Expanded Distribution page says that enrolling doesn’t guarantee any bookseller or library will order your book.
- A team. Editing, design and production are handled for you, and you don’t pay for them upfront.
- Credibility in some fields. Literary fiction and some nonfiction categories still weigh a publisher’s imprint. That varies by genre, and we can’t put a number on it.
What it costs you
Time
There’s no official clock, so treat these as industry estimates. Greenleaf Book Group, a publishing services company, estimates about ten months to find an agent and sell the book, then 9 months to 2 years from sale to publication, averaging around 18 months. It puts the whole process at two to three years. Your own case can run shorter or longer.
Control
The publisher usually has the final say on the title, cover, price and release date, and often asks for significant edits. Read the contract closely, ideally with an agent or a contracts specialist.
Royalties
Traditional royalties are a share of a share. The Authors Guild describes the standard hardcover royalty as 15% of list price and the standard e-book royalty as 25% of the publisher’s net receipts. The Guild’s own worked example for a paperback uses 7.5% of list price. Rates vary by contract, so use these as reference points, not promises.
Your agent’s commission comes out of that. The Guild says 15% of domestic earnings is the generally standard rate, and the agency typically receives the advance first and pays you the remaining 85%.
The earn-out matters too. In the Guild’s example, a $20,000 advance on a $20 book with a 7.5% royalty ($1.50 a copy) means more than 13,300 copies have to sell before you see a royalty check.
What self-publishing pays per copy
On Amazon KDP, the numbers are published and you can check them yourself:
- E-books: a 35% option, or a 70% option (minus delivery costs) for list prices from $2.99 to $12.99 on Amazon.com. KDP raised the top of that band from $9.99 to $12.99 effective July 7, 2026, so older articles that say $9.99 are out of date.
- Paperbacks: a 50% or 60% royalty on Amazon.com (50% at $9.98 or less, 60% at $9.99 or more), minus the printing cost. KDP’s example: a $15 book with a $5.00 printing cost earns $4.00. Through Expanded Distribution the rate drops to 40%, and the same example earns $1.00.
Higher per-copy rates don’t mean higher income. You also pay for or do the editing, cover, formatting and marketing yourself. For a realistic budget, see how much it costs to self-publish a book.
The honest part: the Authors Guild’s 2023 Author Income Survey (covering 2022) found a median book income of $2,000 across all authors, and $10,000 for full-time authors. Self-published full-time authors reported a median of $12,800. Those are medians of people who answered a survey, so they say little about what your first book will earn, and most books earn little in year one on either path.
The query reality
Most queries don’t turn into representation, and there’s no single official acceptance rate. The figures that exist are individual reports. One agent, Jessica Alvarez, reported about 1,650 queries in a year, requested material from about 7%, and signed 10 authors, roughly 0.6% of all queries. That’s one agent’s numbers, and other agents and genres will differ. Another author reported around 600 to 700 rejections before two offers. Treat these as anecdotes, not statistics.
A query needs a specific hook, comparable titles, and a clean, edited opening chapter. Check each agent’s submission page for their rules before you send anything.
How to choose
Ask which of these matters most to you:
- Speed and control. If you want to publish on your own timeline and decide the cover, price and edits, self-publishing fits. Start with our step-by-step self-publishing guide.
- An advance and a team. If you want someone else to carry production costs and pitch to bookstores, and you’re willing to wait, traditional publishing is worth a serious try.
- Bookstore shelves. This is the strongest reason to go traditional. If a self-published paperback is your plan, see how KDP and IngramSpark compare on distribution.
- Money from other sources. Books can support speaking, courses and services. See ways authors make money beyond book sales.
It isn’t an either-or forever. Some authors self-publish one project and query another. And if you self-publish, you’ll need to market the book without a publisher’s budget, so plan for that early.
One step you can take today
Finish and edit the manuscript first, because both paths need it. If you’re stuck there, read how to finish your manuscript. When you’re ready to self-publish, our free 30-Day Author Checklist walks through the steps, and the optional BookPros Author Blueprint ($19) goes deeper if you want a full guide.
Sources
- Amazon KDP: eBook royalty and pricing
- Amazon KDP: Paperback royalty
- Amazon KDP: Expanded Distribution
- Authors Guild: e-book and hardcover royalty rates
- Authors Guild: All about advances
- Authors Guild: Guide to agency agreements
- Authors Guild: 2023 Author Income Survey takeaways
- Greenleaf Book Group: publishing timelines (industry estimate)
- Jessica Alvarez query stats (one agent’s self-reported figures)
Checked November 2026. Policies and prices change, so confirm on the platform before you act.
Written by Aashif Shaikh, SEO & Website Lead, Founder of bookpros.info
Need help with your author website? Contact me.

